Documents Related to Hild v. California Supreme Court, et al.

U.S. District Court N.D.Cal. Case No. C-075107-THE

9th Ciruit Court of Appeals Docket No. 08-15785



Newport Beach law firm, Bisnar & Chase, has sued the California Supreme Court and an Appellate Court, contending that nonpublication and no-citation rules violate Constitutional rights to due process and equal protection under the 14th Amendment.



  1. Complaint
  2. Underlying unpublished appellate opinion
  3. News coverage
  4. Docket Report


Motion to Dismiss

  1. Motion to Dismiss
  2. Opposition to Motion to Dismiss
  3. Reply on Motion to Dismiss
  4. Questions from Judge re Motion to Dismiss
  5. Request to File Supplemental Brief
  6. Order on Motion to Dismiss
  7. Judgment



  1. Notice of Appeal
  2. Civil Appeals Docketing Statement
  3. Docket
  4. Opening Brief
  5. Opposition
  6. Reply
  7. Oral Argument September 15, 2009
  8. Order Denying Appeal September 28, 2009